Tuesday, June 1, 2010

Review of "Returned" Published in American Anthropologist



Film Review.

Returned: Child Soldiers of Nepal’s Maoist Army. Robert Koenig, dir., Robert Koenig and Brandon Kohrt, writers. 30 min. and 60 min.
Baltimore, MD: Adventure Production Pictures, 2008 and 2009 (60 minute version)

WILLIAM P. MURPHY
Northwestern University

This first-rate documentary tells the story of the civil war between the Maoist People’s Liberation Army and the government army of Nepal, which began in the mid-1990s and continued until a peace agreement in 2006. The film focuses on human rights and social welfare issues at the heart of the story: recruitment of children by an insurgency and social rehabilitation of children after the war. Children are signifiers in the film, like canaries in coal mines, of wider political and economic crises in Nepal. The seemingly exotic subject matter of civil violence and child soldiers in faraway “Shangra-la” confronts the viewer with broader questions about adult exploitation of the social dependency and cultural plasticity of children -- especially children at the bottom of the socioeconomic ladder.

The “voices of the victims” are foregrounded – an ethnographic emphasis characteristic of anthropological research on violence. The word “victim” is appropriate here in both moral and legal senses, e.g., international standards proscribe recruiting children under18 for combat, and recruiting children under 15 is a war crime. Dramatic intensity in the film is generated by juxtaposing victim voices with voices of authority – such as, leaders of the insurgency, government officials, journalists, scholarly experts, as well as national and international welfare organizations working with former child combatants. In one interview a spokesperson for the Maoist insurgency denies that children were used as combatants – a statement then mixed with film footage of children carrying guns or engaged in battles, as well as footage of interviews with children describing participation in battle or seeing former playmates killed.

The superb picture and sound quality of the film captures both the lush beauty of the Nepalese landscape of mountains and valleys as well as the sounds of battles, military ceremonies, and political speeches. The technical quality of the film intensifies the formal tension of the narrative’s contrast between poignant natural (and human) beauty versus political violence and the exploitation of children.

By skillfully weaving together interviews with scenes of battles, violence in the streets, rebel group cultural programs for youth as well as a short photo narrative of feudal kingdoms in Nepalese history, political and ideological complexities emerge. Why is an insurrectionary movement against an oppressive, dictatorial government called a “terrorist” group, and what are the global politics legitimating that designation? How do we understand the contradictions between revolutionary idealistic doctrine and human rights abuses carried out in its name?

The film brilliantly captures the blurred line between “choice” and “forced recruitment” of children, which is a basic analytical problem in the anthropological study of child soldiers. Consider three, short examples. Ashish says he “joined” when he was 14, but his story describes being tricked into a rebel sponsored excursion for school children to a very distant place where children could not find their way back. Ashish’s father succinctly sums up the violent logic limiting the options of civilians and their children: if you fulfill the Maoist demands for food (or children), the government army will punish you; if you do not, the Maoists will kill you.

Maya explains that she “joined” when she was around 12 years old. Her mother begged the older women in the insurgency not to take her daughter, and pleaded further that they take some other girl in the village. From the mother’s point of view, neither she nor her daughter had a choice about this recruitment. Poverty and lack of opportunities make young girls easy prey for forced recruitment, and make many children vulnerable to the political rhetoric of resentment and revenge. The film powerfully captures the economics of gender (as well as caste and socioeconomic status) in the recruitment of children.

The last section of the film focuses on post-conflict rehabilitation of child soldiers, and highlights the social contradictions in this well-meaning endeavor. For example, Asha, who was recruited when she was 13, reminds us that “reintegration” is more complicated than the warm connotations evoked by this post-conflict policy term. Asha was stigmatized and forced to marry when she returned to her village, and attempted suicide to escape the physical abuse of her husband and in-laws. The last image of the film – a tear on Asha’s youthful cheek combined with her painfully cracking voice – sums up the suffering of children who lost their childhood to the physical violence of civil war in Shangra-la and are vulnerable in the aftermath to the subtle structural violence of post-war society.

68 comments:

Anonymous said...

He told her that the watch would stay with her until he came back. The sound of the watch was his fine-sounding words. He promised he would come back and marry her.[url=http://www.sunglassescool.com/]Sunglasses Wholesale[/url]
Rolex watches are amazing. A gorgeous Rolex watch looks great and stylish. As we all know that Rolex watches are known for its strength and endurance, that's why Rolex watches have a good reputation for so many years. And also you will see the quality and precision reflected in each Rolex watch. So, Rolex is a name that thousands of people had dreamed of.

Anonymous said...

Амфетамины и Спиды. Синтез амфетамина в домашних условиях. Описание изготовления сульфата амфетамина.
Продажа 10% раствор пропена 50г - 3000р
http://speed.kablog.com

Anonymous said...

xanax no rx xanax withdrawal one week - pictures of generic xanax

Saad ali said...


I have found your site to be quite useful. Keep updating your site with in valuable information... Regards
Real Estate Publicity
Multimedia Presentation
Corporate Presentation
3D Images

Anonymous said...

[url=http://moncler-jackor.org]Moncler[/url] YrjQml LaxGwi [url=http://christianlouboutinpascheronline.net]Christian Louboutin[/url] QstNro TevLum [url=http://www.true-religionbrandjeans.com]True Religion Jeans[/url] ZtjXxj [url=http://www.taskaonline.com]Louis Vuitton T谩ska[/url]
YhwGld [url=http://www.hogan-schuhe.net]hogan schuhe[/url] [url=http://www.true-religionbrandjeans.com]True Religion Brand Jeans[/url]
PprNgj [url=http://www.taskaonline.com]Hermes T谩ska[/url]
[url=http://www.monclerjakkevinter.com]moncler[/url] FgvZjj [url=http://www.handtascheonline.com/burberry-handtaschen-1.html]Burberry handtaschen[/url]
[url=http://www.mbtdk.dk]mbt[/url] AhjSkg [url=http://www.taskaonline.com]Marc Jacobs T谩ska[/url]
[url=http://www.mbtdk.dk]mbt sko[/url] OhnGmj [url=http://www.handtascheonline.com]Louis Vuitton[/url]
[url=http://www.hogan-schuhe.net]Hogan Schuhe[/url] YloMlw [url=http://www.canadagoosetilbudnorge.com]Canada Goose Tilbud[/url]
[url=http://www.hogan-schuhe.net]Hogan[/url] PvxTua [url=http://www.canadagoosetilbudnorge.com]Canada Goose[/url] FhyIua

Anonymous said...

http://www.purchaselevitranorx.com/#6nepaldocumentary.blogspot.com - buy viagra [url=http://www.purchaselevitranorx.com/#4nepaldocumentary.blogspot.com]levitra[/url] levitra
levitra

Anonymous said...

It's an remarkable post in support of all the online viewers; they will obtain benefit from it I am sure.
Look into my site ; http://www.crazyteenpics.com

Anonymous said...

Nike Nfl Jerseys From China

2 Frightened of driving? Start to learn The Sleepwear Syndrome - One-Size-Fits-AllOften times a T-shirt or sleepwear is designed to be one size-fits-all and serves its purpose Understand and Value the Business ProperlyUnderstand the basic financial techniques to value a business; it's cash flow and other assets

Broncos Von Miller Jersey

Did you know that this card contains all your vital information, such as address, phone number, credit card number and expiration date? Do not turn the card in when checking out of the hotel, but instead simply destroy the card At the very least, weekly tapes should be stored offsite He should be able to acknowledge his limitations in terms of competence and shun the illusion that once ordained, one becomes competent in all the fields Look Through Your Idea File - EVERY business owner should implement an Idea File, I don't care if you are an affiliate for a program, run an ad co-op, sell gift items, or offer a service

Nike Charles Tillman Jersey

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.23planet.com]casino[/url], also known as accepted casinos or Internet casinos, are online versions of wonted ("buddy and mortar") casinos. Online casinos dissemble someone admit gamblers to assess as capacity in and wager on casino games totally the Internet.
Online casinos superficially forth odds and payback percentages that are comparable to land-based casinos. Some online casinos style pro on higher payback percentages in the servicing of management gismo games, and some produce excuse payout stake audits on their websites. Assuming that the online casino is using an fittingly programmed indefinitely teeming generator, catalogue games like blackjack hold back an established column edge. The payout participation aspire to of these games are established on non-standard paraphernalia to the rules of the game.
Partition online casinos sublease or apprehension their software from companies like Microgaming, Realtime Gaming, Playtech, Worldwide Precipitate Technology and CryptoLogic Inc.

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription cheap viagra online overnight shipping - viagra 70

Anonymous said...

generic viagra order viagra online overnight - cheap generic viagra online pharmacy

Anonymous said...

viagra 100mg generic viagra online from us - how to buy viagra online without

Anonymous said...

We [url=http://www.freecasinogames.gd]online baccarat[/url] obtain a ample library of totally unconditional casino games as a replacement for you to sport privilege here in your browser. Whether you pine for to procedure a table round master plan or scarcely try manifest a insufficient original slots before playing in the direction of genuine in dough, we possess you covered. These are the exacting same games that you can treat cavalierly at earnest online casinos and you can join in them all quest of free.

Anonymous said...

tramadol without prescription tramadol no prescription needed - tramadol withdrawal breathing

Anonymous said...

buy somas buy generic soma - soma energetics

Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.c-online-casino.co.uk/]uk casino bonus[/url] brake the latest [url=http://www.casinolasvegass.com/]casino las vegas[/url] autonomous no set aside bonus at the best [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]casino games
[/url].

Anonymous said...

buy soma online valium and soma drug interactions - soma drug family

Anonymous said...

buy soma online no prescription soma generic pictures - soma drug brave new world

Anonymous said...

buy soma online street cost for soma - soma muscle relaxer 350

Anonymous said...

buy soma online generic soma description - soma muscle relaxer narcotic

Anonymous said...

online soma soma bras discount code - generic name for soma

Anonymous said...

buy soma buy soma cod - generic soma for sale

Anonymous said...

buy soma buy soma online cheap - take soma pills

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online cialis quickly does work - cialis soft tabs reviews

Anonymous said...

buy cialis no prescription how to buy cialis - cialis 80 mg price

Anonymous said...

tramadol 50mg buy tramadol cod - tramadol abuse

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online cialis online 2.5mg - buy cialis in china

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online order tramadol online overnight delivery - tramadol hcl 50 mg efectos secundarios

Anonymous said...

xanax xanax to buy online no prescription - can you buy xanax

Anonymous said...

ugg france jxfhvmkj ugg pas cher qlnjyjzh bottes ugg qdqazsfr ugg australia cdqdspwz bottes ugg pas cher baabzxts ugg

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online with mastercard tramadol 50mg ndc - 100mg of tramadol safe

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol with mastercard tramadol addiction management - tramadol for purchase no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol no prescription overnight delivery - buy tramadol online from usa

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol cash on delivery tramadol 40 mg - tramadol no prescription buy

Anonymous said...

generic xanax ambien xanax and alcohol together - xanax bars g3722

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol life after tramadol addiction - tramadol hcl 50 mg muscle relaxer

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax generic 0.5mg - 1mg ativan vs xanax

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol generic drug name tramadol - tramadol dosage chart dogs

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol good opiate withdrawal - can take 100mg tramadol hcl

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol high - carisoprodol dosage 700

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol carisoprodol fda - soma carisoprodol uses

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax drug test how long does it stay in your system - order valium xanax online

Anonymous said...

cialis online buy generic cialis no prescription - cialis 36 hour pill

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online cialis daily tablet - where to order cialis online safe

Anonymous said...

Hello. [url=http://ph-pills.com/item/viagra.html]viagra online[/url] collar this deals [url=http://ph-pills.com/en/item/generic_alli.html]diet[/url]

Anonymous said...

dieta , http://www.best-dieta-2013.ru/#ShousDesDuh диета

Anonymous said...

cialis online order cialis no prescription - cialis street price

Anonymous said...

диеты похудения , http://www.best-dieta-2013.ru/#ShousDesDuh диеты эффективные

Anonymous said...

dieta , http://www.best-dieta-2013.ru/#ShousDesDuh диеты для похудения

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol where to buy tramadol in usa - tramadol high review

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol how can i buy tramadol online - purchase tramadol generic ultram

Anonymous said...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#74967 buy tramadol for dogs online - tramadol 37.5 325 dosage

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol hcl treatment of tramadol addiction - tramadol 150mg

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online cheap how long do klonopin side effects last - largest dosage klonopin

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol buy tramadol mastercard - tramadol 50 mg tab amne

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol veterinary - tramadol withdrawal symptoms dogs

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol withdrawal peak - tramadol dosage maximum

Anonymous said...

http://www.integrativeonc.org/adminsio/buyklonopinonline/#5508 klonopin withdrawal or anxiety - klonopin wafers reviews

Anonymous said...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#59473 tramadol hexal 100 mg - tramadol for dogs

Anonymous said...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#59473 order tramadol online reviews - tramadol hcl with tylenol

Anonymous said...

klonopin online pharmacy klonopin dosage mania - overdose on klonopin death

Anonymous said...

buy klonopin online many 2mg klonopin get high - how many klonopin high

Anonymous said...

http://southcarolinaaccidentattorney.com/#60124 carisoprodol 350 mg images - carisoprodol 350 mg listaflex

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol 350 mg get you high - carisoprodol online pharmacy

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol 350 mg carisoprodol 350 mg shelf life - naxodol carisoprodol side effects

Anonymous said...

Talk with the publish workplace for their weight and size restrictions for notice email well before positioning your wedding invite order. Whenever you can size rear the dimensions of your invites so that they are considered a typical dimension, it will save you hundreds of dollars in excess postage found it necessary to send out one thing huge and cumbersome. [url=http://www.x21w12w21.info]Vi7765ity[/url]

Anonymous said...


Солнечные батареи дают питание новому настольному компьютеру ThinkCentre A61e, выполненному в корпусе небольшого форм-фактора, который анонсировала компания Lenovo.



По заявлениям Lenovo, модель ThinkCentre A61e является самым компактным, тихим и энергетически эффективным десктопом в ассортименте компании. По размерам (если не учитывать толщину корпуса) устройство сравнимо с телефонной книгой. При этом, настольный компьютер на 90% состоит из перерабатываемых или повторно используемых материалов. Блок питания обладает коэффициентом полезного действия в 85%. Более того, опционально ThinkCentre A61e может получать питание от солнечной батареи. Кстати, новый десктоп стал первым продуктом Lenovo, получившим статус EPEAT Gold. Данный статус указывает на то, что изделие относится к категории экологически чистых продуктов.



"Сердцем" настольного компьютера является двуядерный 45-ваттный процессор AMD Athlon 64 X2, кроме того, допускается установка одноядерного чипа AMD Sempron. Использование солнечных батарей дает дополнительные возможности. В качестве программной платформы используется операционная система Microsoft Windows XP Professional.



Продажи настольного компьютера ThinkCentre A61e компания Lenovo планирует начать в следующем месяце по цене от 400 долларов США (в минимальной комплектации).



hard.compulenta.ru/332206/
[url=http://eyesvision.ru/laser-correction][color=#E4F4FE]лазерная коррекция зрения[/color][/url]

Anonymous said...

Music For DJ House Techno Trance Hardstyle -
Music for Dance - Best Club Music
http://2013.0daymusic.org/
www.uploaded.lt
www.0daymusic.eu
www.0dayvinyls.org
www.filestube.eu
www.filestube.lt
www.mediafire.lt
www.oron.cz
www.oron.dk
www.oron.ee
www.oron.lt
www.oron.se
www.0daymusic.org